For a first Shanghai visit, I'd compare a hotel around People's Square or East Nanjing Road with one around Jing'an. Choose the first when the Bund and classic sightseeing lead the plan; choose the second when you want restaurants, neighborhood wandering and a conventional city-hotel base. A leafy street in Xuhui is another good direction if the walking itself is what you enjoy.

I would only choose Lujiazui for a specific reason: a room view you value, work on that side of the river, or the kind of modern hotel you want. “Pudong” is a large location label, not a promise that you will be close to the skyline. The hotel's precise pin matters much more.

A useful first shortlist

A useful first shortlist
Search areaBest reason to consider itMain compromise to investigate
People's Square / East Nanjing RoadA short first visit focused on central sightsBusy streets, room noise and the real entrance location
Jing'anA balanced base for eating, shopping and city outingsWhether your chosen hotel is in the part of Jing'an you expect
Xuhui / western HuangpuTree-lined walking and neighborhood cafésThe exact station connection and older-building facilities
LujiazuiPudong plans or a skyline-focused hotel stayRepeated journeys to your Puxi activities
Hongqiao areaAn onward journey, exhibition or work commitmentDistance from the central sightseeing you intend to do
Airport / resort areaA flight or a specific resort-led stayWhether moving hotels is worthwhile for your wider visit

Shanghai's official district overview helps locate Huangpu, Jing'an, Xuhui and Pudong. Use it for orientation, then narrow the search to a station or a few streets.

People's Square and East Nanjing Road

Start here if you want a recognizable base for an introductory Shanghai visit. Save 人民广场 and 南京东路 while comparing addresses. The attraction is convenience for the kind of central wandering many first-time visitors want; the trade-off is that convenience can come with a busy street outside.

For a hotel near a pedestrian area, ask where a vehicle can actually stop. Check the entrance image, floor and elevator access, especially in a mixed-use building. I'd put a clear entrance and a quiet room ahead of a small saving on a room whose location is difficult to understand.

A “Bund hotel” description needs another look. Does it mean a waterfront address, a view from one room category, or simply somewhere within a broad surrounding area? Compare the room you are buying, not the most impressive photograph in the listing.

Jing'an, 静安, suits travelers who want the hotel surroundings to work for dinner and everyday errands as well as sightseeing. I'd compare properties around a useful station rather than selecting the district filter and sorting only by price.

Put your actual plans into a map: an evening on the Bund, a museum, a day in the streets around your hotel, and your departure. A base that works across those journeys is more valuable than the one that wins a single airport-trip comparison.

If you are traveling with family, compare usable room space, beds and laundry options. For a working stay, check the desk and Wi-Fi arrangement directly with the property. A polished lobby doesn't establish either.

Xuhui and western Huangpu: choose the streets

This is the direction I'd look for a trip built around walking, cafés and time between formal sights. The phrase “former French Concession” covers an area of the city rather than one compact attraction or one hotel district. Pin the particular streets you want to wander, then look for a room that fits them.

A converted or older building can be appealing, but ask about stairs, window type, air conditioning and bathroom layout. Recent guest comments about noise and maintenance tell you more than a carefully composed photograph of a lane entrance.

Be realistic about your walking preferences. If you like a slow start, a local breakfast and an unplanned turn down a side street, the setting is part of the stay. If every morning begins with a distant appointment, a simpler station connection might serve you better.

Lujiazui: book the view deliberately

Lujiazui, 陆家嘴, is the familiar tower district across the river from the Bund. I'd choose it when the view or a Pudong commitment is a meaningful part of the visit. I wouldn't choose a distant Pudong property on the assumption that the district name places it beside those towers.

If you are paying for a view, ask what the particular room category faces and whether the photograph is taken from that room. A river glimpse, a full skyline view and a view from a restaurant are different things. Decide whether you'd rather spend that money on the room or on meals and experiences around the city.

Trace the route to your evening plans. Returning to the room is part of the outing, especially with children or after a late dinner. Neither side of the river is automatically the wrong choice; the right side is the one that matches your days.

When an outer base makes sense

Hongqiao, 虹桥, deserves consideration when an exhibition, business appointment or onward journey leads the stay. An airport or resort-area hotel can also solve a specific arrival or departure problem. Check the actual airport and station names: a hotel saying “airport shuttle” still needs a destination, pickup point and operating arrangement.

For a sightseeing visit, I'd usually keep the central nights together. Moving hotels consumes attention even when it looks efficient on a map. Split the stay when it clearly removes a difficult journey, not just to try another neighborhood.

Before paying, send the property your expected arrival, guest details and that you will use foreign passports. Request the Chinese address and suggested station exit or car drop-off. Save the confirmation offline. Then make your Pudong arrival plan around that address, rather than choosing the hotel to fit a transport ride you have already decided to take.